2012-10-25

Rebalance dreads? Nah...

I was following this thread with great interest. There have been many like it before. The number of voices raised for nerfing the mighty Moros only compares to the ones shouting for a better Naglfar. Not many seems to care for the Phoenix, maybe it is just to ugly to get any love?

When you read the forums, you might think there's a consensus about that the dreads are, in fact, terribly unbalanced. You look at how they compare against each other and draw the conclusion that Moros and Revelations are both good, useful ships but the Phoenix pretty much useless. The Naglfar is ok, but only because it's vertical.

But should we really compare them like that? Why do we want them to be "balanced" so they all are exchangeable with each other? What if you actually like the fact that they all have their different use?

Is it that a Moros can do everything a Phoenix can (maybe not as well) but not vice versa? Is that what's unbalanced?

I don't fly dreads myself, so my thoughts might not carry much weight, but at the same time I hear so much about "how ships are" from people that have no clue of their own, but just pick up on what's written and take that for facts, so I thought I could at least have an opinion.

"The Phoenix is terrible!" - yes, if you look at it as a Caldari version of the Moros it is. But if your objective is to reinforce a POS and incapacitate some mods it's the perfect tool. It's quite tanky, it can adapt dmg type and it have a range that are suspiciously close to what you would need if you wanted to park it beside a POS and still reach any defence anchored.

Ok, you need to be there and actually press the F1 once in a while, but dread-sieges are not nearly as prolonged as BS ones, so the 'afk-ability' a Geddon have over, say a Raven, is not such a big deal with Dreads. Or so I would imagine.

"The Naglfar is sub par due to the split weapon system" - hmm.. maybe. But I see a trend here. Many Minmatar ships are a bit strange in that they don't lean heavy towards one specific doctrine (active/passive/armor/shield/nano/brick), it's almost like they are made to be platforms "for out of the box"-thinking...

Maybe the Naglfar is the same. A Naglfar should be able to do 7k dps with decent tracking and have room for RR and/or cap-transfers. Wait? What? you talking about utility high-slots on a dread? Maybe. As I said, I don't fly the darn things myslef, so this is just theorizing to make a point.
But maybe it's what happend here?

That leaves the Revelation. The Rev is considered equal to the Moros, but it don't have the dps nor the performance against sub-caps (lower tracking). On paper, the Moros seams to do everything the rev does, but better. So what raison d'ĂȘtre do the Rev have? With my they don't need to be exchangeable! thesis, the Moros, Phoenix and Naglfar all have their niche, but the Rev is only a laser version of the Moros. How fun is that?

So drop the idea that a dread is a dread is a dread for a moment.
  • Moros - Versatile, sub-cap killer, capital blaster boat
  • Phoenix - The ultimate POS-bash platform.
  • Revelation - Good dps and flexible range, afk-able, ammo-less
  • Naglfar - Experimentation platform, up for any task

I sort of like it like this.

You only need a "rebalance" if some ships are totally left out of the equation because they are surpassed in every way by some other ship. I don't think that's the case with dreads, they all have their flavor. Multiple flavors make interesting choices, and that's a cornerstone in any good game design.


2012-10-23

180M/h - easy ISK

Today, I logged on two hours before downtime to find a single corp mate active in Picasso (our home C5). Since our static C4 happend to be a magnetar with 7 plexes in it, I asked Xinnax if he wanted to kill some sleepers. A magnetar C4 and two Tengus make for pretty sweet and easy ISK. If you are opportunistic that is.

The static was inhabited and pretty well kept, so apart from the static WH and our K162, there where only 2 ladars in there. Nice and quick to scan down. I put my boosting toon on the static as a scout and Xinnax flew a salvager on his other account. Four ships, two pilots, seven sites to do and 2 hours until downtime - would we make it?

Seven sites later, 730M ISK richer and with the 5 minutes downtime counter on our screens we warped back to Picasso. Since Xinnax had done the salvage as we went, this was pretty efficient plexing.

The thing is, we can do this at any time. It might not be as perfect setup as it was today. Our static C4 might not be a mag and have a few incoming WHs you need to deal with first, but that's not something we don't have a solution for.

And it only takes two pilots. Without a booster you need to be a bit more careful, and without a salvage-alt, you need to do the salvage afterwards. But except from that, all that's really needed more than the Tengus is a scout that can have ears at the static and do a scan for new WHs now and then.

Not the worst ISK/h and not the best either, but it's R-NAT's main income at the moment. And it's easy to setup and get going.

2012-10-18

The definition of a gank

"good fight", "gank", "PVP-fit", "carebear", "blob" - expressions that we all know and use often. But are we in total consensus about the meanings of the words?

For example, what exactly is a gank? What makes a gank a gank? Is a gank opposed to a fight, or can a fight be a gank? Is it defined by overwhelming numbers? Maybe it's dependant on the victims having non-pvp fits? Nah, that's not it, is it?

Perhaps a gank have to do with the element of surprise, that the victims did not know it was coming? Or does it have to do with dps? Can a frig gank a ratting BS?

Or is it simply the right combination of all of the above?

Lets say you find a Drake in a C2 plex. Based on some info/knowledge you give it a 80% chance being bait. There's most likely a fleet behind a WH, somewhere, waiting.

Lets also say that you belong to a corp with big balls and/or a wallet fat enough to take the bait without having a clue about the size of the waiting fleet.

Are you ganking the Drake? He know you (or something) is coming, so it's not a surprise. He also most likely have a point and a tank made for survive long enough for his friends to arrive.

More interestingly, will the resulting fight (when everybody get on grid) be a fight or a gank? If it's a gank, who is ganking who?

Or what about this;
- I was taking my Proteus in, but got ganked on the way
- By what?
- A Pilgrim and a Sabre...
- You mean you fought two ships and lost?
- yea, that's what I said!

Is it it simply down to who chooses to engage and who is forced to fight?

Sometimes I get the feeling the word is so broad and carries so many different meanings for so many pilots it's almost useless. Still if I say "gank" instead of fight I imply that it was single-sided, and that the ganked party did not have a chance. That's a good nuance I guess, but it only works when the gank succeeds.

If I find 4 dudes plexing in a C5 and jump them with 12 ships put together especially to kill them, but somehow underestimates their fleet or otherwise mess up getting all of my fleet killed and fail to kill any of them - did I gank them? And surly nobody would say "we tried to kill a few guys plexing, but they ganked us so we lost our fleet"? :)

Another word that is pretty devalued is "blob". Does it have to do with absolute numbers? Is 200 dudes flying Drakes in nullsec a blob? Or does it have to do with relative numbers? Do the 200-man Drake fleet become a blob when they warp in on the 30 man AHAC fleet? Do six Canes "blob" a single plexing drake?

Answering all or any of this questions don't really add anything, it's just fun to ask them. People understand each other anyhow.

However, I don't put "gf" in local after we have killed some plexers using a fleet three times their numbers. Because it was not, it was neither a fight nor any good. Not good for them, and per definition, not a fight for us. The goodness was all on our side, and the fight where nowhere to be seen.

That's where I draw the line.


2012-10-17

Missile-discussion: Out of focus?

About the coming changes to heavy missiles and then sometime after that, Tracking Computers, Tracking Enhancers and Tracking Links - the discussion are not focusing on the interesting stuff!

Most of the responses and discussion have been around heavy missiles and how it will affect Tengu and Drake pilots. For w-space use, the opinions seams to cover a broad spectra from "all missile-users will have to adapt!" to "nothing really going to change, you will kill sleepers a bit slower, that's all"

I subscribe to the latter, hence I don't find the effects on HM/Tengu/Drake so interesting. I think the whole discussion focuses on the wrong things. Maybe this will totally break the Drake as a fleet ship in null-sec, but (as a w-space dweller) who cares? :)

What might be very interesting is the effects of introducing a module (three actually!) that can affect the range of any missile. Missile range was only affected by skills, implants and rigs before, which took some dedication and/or planing if you for example wanted to use torps for reaching 30+ km for that sweet DPS against a POS.

There are some ships that all of a sudden could be viable for something they previously was not used for because there was some other ship that did it better, or with lower skill-requirements.

This might affect many different setups, and I'm not going to pretend I have thought of half of them.

So, lets just take torps, range and POS'es as an example;
  • I would for example not be surprised if we did see people doing funky things with stealth bombers and Javelin torps to "snipe" POS defences out of disruptor/gun range.
  • A T2 fitted Raven needs both BS 5 and rigs to be useful for a POS-bash (if you want to use Rage torps). With a few mods to push the range to 35km I bet we will see more torp ships like the Raven making it top 5 damage on POS kill mails in the future.
  • Ships with split weapon-systems that both needs range (like the Typhoon) for optimal dps against a large POS might also benefit hugely from a mod that boosts the range of them both.
  • With the right pilot, the Rattlesnake will most definitely secure top position for sub-caps on every POS KM out there. The laser-boats will still be more comfy, because you can afk them. For the rattler, only the sentry-part of its applied damage will be afk'able. On the other hand, the torp damage can target any resist holes there might be.
  • All of a sudden, a top skilled Rattler pilot will be able to do close to 1200 dps @ +30km. And have a tank. And have the option of adapting damage-projection to smaller stuff (switching to smaller drones and tracking scripts).

2012-10-16

C4: No, it's not a trap

It's time to realise that in most cases, people don't know what they are doing. At least in the C4-tier of w-space where we currently roam. Some of the pilots in R-NAT that are still new to w-space always overestimate the opposition. They think everybody else have the same information (or more) then them. They suspect a trap everywhere and believe that people are always doing the smart thing.

If one drop probes in a system and then five minutes later a hauler goes out to a planet to do PI it got to be a trap because they know we are here, right? They must have seen our probes!

There is a thesis called Occams Razor. It more or less states that "one should proceed to simpler theories until simplicity can be traded for greater explanatory power."

Simplest explanation is often the correct one, in this, not so hypothetical, case - that PI dude simply did not d-scan the system. Simple as that.

In fact, it was pretty evident that they had not seen us lurking around, because five minutes later they set out to plex in three Tengus. One survived.

The fit on those also shows that people in C4s in general don't know what they are doing. Interdiction nullified? That did not help them much. Buffer-fit with RR? MWDs? And what's up with the medium shield transporter? I guess that's all part of some clever idea that would make perfect sense if I only knew what they where thinking.

Or maybe not...


2012-10-15

Getting settled: PVE backbone

We are starting to get comfy in our new home. The kills we done so far are mostly ganks of solo plexers or industrials, and they are the result of a one or two in corp that actually finding the time to do the scanning/scouting required.

I'm hoping we will see more of our pilots doing that when we are all more situated, POS'es setup, ships brought in etc...

When it comes to using the assets we now have for personal wealth generation, a.k.a plexing, I don't think we have even started.

Some of us fly caps and there is a project going to do some proper C5 escalations, but it's still in it's infancy. We are doing some escalations, but with Tengus as dps. It works more as a fun thing and as good training for carrier pilots than proper generation of ISK.

I have used our static C4 for some soloing using my trusty Rattler once, but I don't think we see Tengu-gangs regularly plexing that yet. To be honest, I have not started any of those fleets myself, but I put that down to having to bloody much too do with corporate things, director as I am...

Grabbing a Tengu and a friend or two and running some sites in our static C4 is probably the quickest and most effective way to do some ISK for the R-NAT pilots now.


2012-10-12

Too little respect

We managed to lose a Tengu plexing (sigh!) a few days ago. And it was not even an escalation. Just a normal Mag site in our home C5.

Last wave in this particular magsite consists of 5 Sleepless Keepers, and they are quite nasty (not at all as the escalation spawns, but still not to be taken lightly).

We lost the Tengu from a combination of three mistakes stacking on top of each other. If you read avionics crash reports this is often exactly what happens, it seldom just one problem/mistake, it's the combination that brings a plane down.
  1. We had perfect boosts, but because of a dual-boxing related mistake on my part the links was off when we needed them as most.
  2. Second mistake was a piloting one. The fleet failed to keep the Tengu that got into trouble in range which means he did not receive full reps. Making sure everybody are in range of each other is vital if you rely on a spider-tank.
  3. Third error was a fitting one. The Tengu lost was not fitted according to corp doctrine, and thus might have had some problems doing what was expected of it. Note that this have nothing to do with however that fit is worse or better, it's more a question of knowing the ships capabilities.

But mostly this was related to us taking the sleepers lightly. Something you really never can do.

One risk with doing higher end PVE content is that you lose respect for the lower types. Combine that with a long period of not even having put your foot in a C5 mag, if ever, and you might get into trouble. Single escalations are easy, so surly we can handle a normal magsite without a carrier and only a few Tengus, right?

I remember not even looking through what kind of sleepers there where in the different waves when we started, I just wanted to get going and thought we could get a few additional Tengus in if it got to dicey.

Stop treating w-space PVE content as a real threat and it will prove you wrong.

2012-10-10

The sad state of WH pvp

I have with increasing surprise followed this thread on the forums.

Oxandrolone from Elysian Empire commented on the problem of getting a good fight in w-space, and that it is so hard to kill PVE caps doing sites.

My surprise comes from the fact that it's from one of the alliances that "have made it" in w-space. Guys that have the numbers and knowledge to turn the ISK faucet all the way up. A group that should have all options in the world and that spend very little time (relatively) getting their ISK. They can use their time to go look for pvp, and when they find it they can afford to put bling on the line to counter a possibly larger fleet.

Seriously, they have the numbers, the means to make ISK, the time, the knowledge as well as the best possible ships and they are complaining it's hard to find fights?

There is also a effect that if you are a large alliance, you don't get fights just because everybody assumes you have a triage-backed, 20-man T3 fleet ready to pounce and a Moros or two on standby.

Elysian Empire have (I assume) worked a bit to get to the size they are now because just because they want to be able to field that exact type of fleet that smaller corporations fear. They want the "blobbing". At least the option of blobbing. Or at the very least not want to be on the wrong side of it.

I'm not trashing Elysian as such, if somebody in Transmission Lost complained about the same thing I would simply ask are you sure you are living in the right kind of system? And with the right corp/alliance? By being large you have a number of advantages, but you also need to deal with people not wanting to fight if you constantly use that size (which is hard not to - larger numbers is a powerful tactic). What you can't do is complain about it.

My alliance is the biggest w-space entity out there, but we are much, much more heterogeneous then most others. I think this is true for alliance number two, Talocan, as well. There are a few corporations in Transmission Lost that live in the same system and work as a unit when it comes to pvp, but we most definitely don't represent any one type of w-space as an alliance. As much as I hate the word in RL, Transmission Lost is truly multicultural.

That's why, from my perspective, I find it terribly amusing;
  1. To hear our diplo try to explain for Two step that large parts of TL live in a C2 because they want to. Because that's where they find the pvp they want. The concept of a large corp NOT striving for cap-warefare in C5/C6 seams totally lost on some (no pun intended).
  2. At the same time hear a C5/C6 alliance complain about how they can't get fights. And to add insult to injury can't even kill carebears that use the same mechanism as they do to get ISK
  3. Then, amazingly, hear that the very same group in Transmission Lost that for some time have done the most number of kills/fights/ganks in shallow w-space now wants to go deeper into w-space to find "the big fights". The fights that some of the dragons complain don't exist.
  4. All this while we (LOST) actually have a group of corps that time and time again show that there are fights to be had in C5s. And they kill their fair share of plexers when they happen to roll into some. (and yes, that is the same group that amused us all with their successful defence last month)

It feels like what many have not understood is that w-space is what you make it.

Cipreh, the CEO of another Transmission Lost corp that have chosen not to venture into deeper parts of w-space, posted a very nice comment that reflects what I think.

Don't want to fight big gangs? Don't join a corp/alliance that field big fleets. Don't want cap-fights? Don't live in a C5/C6. Want to be able to prowl w-space killing the occasional gasser or PI dude? Make sure you have a static C2. Want to make sure your pilots can make good ISK and find pvp on their own? Get a static C3. Want to foster team-thinking and do your ISK/pvp with small fleets instead of solo? Get a static C4.

I think that Hidden Fremen from lead Farmers summed it up pretty well;
Yes, please just go look for fights. Go balls deep. It's the best deep. Half the fun used to be going down the rabbit hole. Then you got big and now you can't be bothered to go beyond your static (this is to whoever complains they can't find caps to gank during chain-roling "PvP").


2012-10-09

Another day in the WH

Lets see what I have done today. I do believe I've been a real busy bee!

I logged on and was directly called to arms because our scouts waited for a Tengu in our chain to probe down a specific WH and jump through, so we could kill it. "something with a quick lock" was required so I spent 20 min at said WH in a Sabre.

No Tengu though. It most likely found the highsec instead and thought that was more interesting. Can't blame him, I opted to use the very same HS 10 min later when I had to go to empire to buy some rigs for one of our tengus. One jump to Amarr is just to good to be wasted.

When I came back and had fixed the Tengu up, I anchored two more SMAs at our POS. Until we get some more towers up in here we needed a place to stuff some ships that been floating around.

By now our scouts had solved the mystery with the disappearing Tengu and had a new theory; the Tengu was in fact a scout for some nullsecers taking some ships home via w-space. This day they had only 5 jumps to Ammar - great use of w-space!

We had several drakes, a and sacrelige on scan, so we fleeted up in Tengus hoping we could catch some of them. Or get a fight. Maybe. Earlier we had jumped the gun a little bit and showed our hand. This time we where to slow jumping a WH and failed to get a bubble on the HS before a whole slew of pods and haulers landed and jumped to safety.

At least we got one of the drakes.

I had not been back in our POS for long before alliance chat started to blink and another target of opportunity showed up. This time in the form of "a small, non-stronted POS in 50% shields 5j from Amarr" wait a minute! Was not our static super-close to Amarr? Sure was, so without thinking to much about what ship to bring, I switched fleet and com-channel and started to head for the target system.

While getting there I get the sitrep. Apparently Clann Fian had found a totally undefended small POS that was in reinforced and only had a few hours left. They had left a scout in system and now, a few hours since the POS had become vulnerable again, they could offer a route in.

The actual POS-kill goes quick and was uneventful. That is, until there only was a sliver of structure left and the tower was on the verge of popping. Then, with what must be the worst timing ever, a Tengu logs in. He lands in the POS just seconds before the tower explodes and the shields drop.

He gets locked up, pointed and more or less alphaed by our Oracles. Turns out he was totally unfitted. Figure that.

2012-10-07

Starting up plexing again

We did our first C5 escalation in a long time today. We been lingering around in C4 and C2s long enough, now it's time to do some real ISK! Its only PVE of course, but it's going to be the core of our development.

Not having to think too hard about how much things cost, and being able to lose some ships gaining experience will make it more fun to do what we are set on doing - improving our pew-pew-skills.

We have all this sites in our new home system, but we don't quite have the ships in to do it proper "Jack Miton style" Yes, I sometimes go hard on the guy on the forums because he comes across like a elitist prick, but he do know his stuff - read the guide.

So, we improvised a bit with what we had, and did the first escalation with a Thanathos and some Tengus, and then simply escalated by bouncing a second and third cap into the site and back to the POS. Doing the escalations one by one. Not at all as efficient as possible, but it got the job done.

Besides, we are all a little more then rusty on this whole cap flying business. Many of our pilots have been away from C5/C6 action for almost a year. It's good to start easy.

And here I go writing about PVE stuff again...

2012-10-06

Small lessons

Sitrep: we got eyes on a Orca that are moving about in a POS situated in a C3 with a static HS. For once we where actually looking primarily for empire and not for someone to kill, but there you go..

Since there is a chance that Orca might warp to the HS I ask our scout if the POS is in d-scan range of the HS. I'm told it's not so I grab a cloaky HIC and go to bubble that wormhole in the hopes of catching a Orca.

I warp to it directly at zero because I'm intending to put up the bubble anyway.

Just a few minutes after I land i get word that the Orca pilot changed into a industrial, so we all took bets that there was PI to be done. Sure enough, the Mammoth warps to planet five. Planet five happens to be in scan-range of the static WH where i hang with a Onyx.

Now I need to cloak the f*k up (ctfu?:) and that quick before I spook our industrial friend... Being at zero on a WH don't help :(

We are just seconds of getting a scram on him, and that's most likely because he saw the HIC on scan and decided that the PI could wait, turned on the spot and warped back to his POS.

1 minute later he was back in the Orca and logged off.

Lesson: Make sure you can cloak at all times!

This should be is sort of obvious for any wormholer, but for some reason I managed to forget about this just because I was not in a 'cloaky ship'. My bad!

2012-10-04

The smiling WH gods

We must have been doing something to please the gods as of late.

Just as we needed a good route into Picasso (our new home system) a divine present appeared on scan.

[21:37:33] Rogeroo > think we need to bring in fuel and rerolling fleet next
[21:37:35] Qumar Nuom > what NS connection do we have?
[21:37:45] Rogeroo > i dont know
[21:37:57] Rogeroo > is not scanned down
[21:37:57] Talaq > i think ashi said it was bad
[21:40:39] Talaq > the c3 guys were rerolling i heard
[21:41:02] Rogeroo > new sig in picasso
[21:41:15] Qumar Nuom > incoming HS hurray :P
[21:44:30] Rogeroo > HS !!!
[21:44:33] Rogeroo > outgoing
[21:44:34] Qumar Nuom > haha
[21:44:40] Qumar Nuom > hurray
[21:44:58] Qumar Nuom > its all about positive thinking I guess
[21:45:27] Rogeroo > the WH gods are smiling

With a direct highsec we could autopilot Orcas strait into Picasso! It could not get much easier! The only question is what have we done to be so blessed by Bob?

My guess is might have something to do with this... It was Sephi that found a few gassers in a C5 comming from our static C4. Or rather, she had strong reasons to believe that the inhabitants of the C4 had jumped into said C5 and that she was going to see them on directional, sucking on some cloud, as soon as she jumped in there.

The plan was as simple as it was devious - jump in, launch combats and hope that would scare them to warp back home to their C4. Home, and right into the arms of our waiting (cloaky) ships at the c4/c5 wormhole.

It worked like a charm.

I can only take the recent events as a sure sign that Bob likes when you kill gas-miners.




2012-10-03

A new home!

Sometimes things take unexpected turns. R-NATs plans for finding a new home - specifically a C5 with a static C4, preferably a magnetar - got a bit derailed a few days ago.

The plan was to use the stage-system we had (with a static C5) and simply roll until we found something we liked. An added bonus would be we could then get a few caps into the new system right at the get go. A system that I thought would be a bit hard to get caps into because it not having a suitable static.

As it turns out, there's no lack whatsoever of incoming C5/C6/LS/NS that you can use for jump dreads and carriers in.

It also happens that Rogeroo had some friend of a friend that actually had a scout in one of the two C5/C4 magnetars that we where interested in. So it was decided we should go for that one instead of rolling.

We lifted the two caps we had in the stage system out to empire, and started to move the few ships we had out. The next day the POS was uneventfully taken down and shipped out to Empire.

We got a few scouts into what was to become our new home. All was set for the big move!