I was following this thread with great interest. There have been many like it before. The number of voices raised for nerfing the mighty Moros only compares to the ones shouting for a better Naglfar. Not many seems to care for the Phoenix, maybe it is just to ugly to get any love? When you read the forums, you might think there's a consensus about that the dreads are, in fact, terribly unbalanced. You look at how they compare against each other and draw the conclusion that Moros and Revelations are both good, useful ships but the Phoenix pretty much useless. The Naglfar is ok, but only because it's vertical.
But should we really compare them like that? Why do we want them to be "balanced" so they all are exchangeable with each other? What if you actually like the fact that they all have their different use?
Is it that a Moros can do everything a Phoenix can (maybe not as well) but not vice versa? Is that what's unbalanced?
I don't fly dreads myself, so my thoughts might not carry much weight, but at the same time I hear so much about "how ships are" from people that have no clue of their own, but just pick up on what's written and take that for facts, so I thought I could at least have an opinion.
"The Phoenix is terrible!" - yes, if you look at it as a Caldari version of the Moros it is. But if your objective is to reinforce a POS and incapacitate some mods it's the perfect tool. It's quite tanky, it can adapt dmg type and it have a range that are suspiciously close to what you would need if you wanted to park it beside a POS and still reach any defence anchored.
Ok, you need to be there and actually press the F1 once in a while, but dread-sieges are not nearly as prolonged as BS ones, so the 'afk-ability' a Geddon have over, say a Raven, is not such a big deal with Dreads. Or so I would imagine.
"The Naglfar is sub par due to the split weapon system" - hmm.. maybe. But I see a trend here. Many Minmatar ships are a bit strange in that they don't lean heavy towards one specific doctrine (active/passive/armor/shield/nano/brick), it's almost like they are made to be platforms "for out of the box"-thinking...
Maybe the Naglfar is the same. A Naglfar should be able to do 7k dps with decent tracking and have room for RR and/or cap-transfers. Wait? What? you talking about utility high-slots on a dread? Maybe. As I said, I don't fly the darn things myslef, so this is just theorizing to make a point.
But maybe it's what happend here?
That leaves the Revelation. The Rev is considered equal to the Moros, but it don't have the dps nor the performance against sub-caps (lower tracking). On paper, the Moros seams to do everything the rev does, but better. So what raison d'ĂȘtre do the Rev have? With my they don't need to be exchangeable! thesis, the Moros, Phoenix and Naglfar all have their niche, but the Rev is only a laser version of the Moros. How fun is that?
So drop the idea that a dread is a dread is a dread for a moment.
- Moros - Versatile, sub-cap killer, capital blaster boat
- Phoenix - The ultimate POS-bash platform.
- Revelation - Good dps and flexible range, afk-able, ammo-less
- Naglfar - Experimentation platform, up for any task
I sort of like it like this.
You only need a "rebalance" if some ships are totally left out of the equation because they are surpassed in every way by some other ship. I don't think that's the case with dreads, they all have their flavor. Multiple flavors make interesting choices, and that's a cornerstone in any good game design.
Today, I logged on two hours before downtime to find a single corp mate active in Picasso (our home C5). Since our static C4 happend to be a magnetar with 7 plexes in it, I asked Xinnax if he wanted to kill some sleepers. A magnetar C4 and two Tengus make for pretty sweet and easy ISK. If you are
"good fight", "gank", "PVP-fit", "carebear", "blob" - expressions that we all know and use often. But are we in total consensus about the meanings of the words?
About the
It's time to realise that in most cases, people don't know what they are doing. At least in the C4-tier of w-space where we currently roam. Some of the pilots in R-NAT that are still new to w-space always overestimate the opposition. They think everybody else have the same information (or more) then them. They suspect a trap everywhere and believe that people are always doing the smart thing.
We are starting to get comfy in our new home. The kills we done so far are mostly
We managed to lose a Tengu plexing (sigh!) a few days ago. And it was not even an escalation. Just a normal Mag site in our home C5.
I have with increasing surprise followed
Lets see what I have done today. I do believe I've been a real busy bee!
We did our first C5 escalation in a long time today. We been lingering around in C4 and C2s long enough, now it's time to do some real ISK! Its only PVE of course, but it's going to be the core of our development.
Sitrep: we got eyes on a Orca that are moving about in a POS situated in a C3 with a static HS. For once we where actually looking primarily for empire and not for someone to kill, but there you go..
We must have been doing something to please the gods as of late.
Sometimes things take unexpected turns. R-NATs plans for finding a new home - specifically a C5 with a static C4, preferably a magnetar - got a bit derailed a few days ago.